What to Ask an SEO Company Before You Sign Anything

Owner at a disadvantage, and aware of it. That is how the meeting starts. The provider talks about authority and crawl budget and domain metrics, the owner nods, and the proposal gets signed on gut feel about whether the person seemed credible. Gut feel is not useless. It is also not enough, and the gap gets expensive. You do not need to understand SEO to evaluate someone who does. You need about eight questions and a sense of what a weak answer sounds like. Nineteen years of sitting on the other side of this table, and the questions that separate real providers from the rest are consistently the same ones.

“What Will You Do in the First Ninety Days?”

Specifics or nothing. A real answer names an audit, particular technical fixes, keyword research, and a content plan with rough quantities attached. Weak answer: “We will optimize your site and build authority.” That sentence contains no commitment. Ask it again, more directly. What gets fixed, in what order, and how will I know it happened.

“Who Actually Works on My Account?”

Agencies sell with senior people and deliver with junior ones. Standard practice, not a scandal, but you should know before signing rather than after. Ask who does the work day to day. Ask how many other accounts that person carries. Ask whether you can speak to them directly. Twenty accounts to one junior means your site gets a template.

“Show Me a Client You Helped in a Similar Position”

Not a logo wall. A specific account, what shape it was in when they took it over, what changed, over what period. The good version of this answer includes something that did not work. Every real campaign has a stretch where a bet did not pay off, and a provider who describes only unbroken success is describing a sales deck rather than a client. Ranked keyword examples with the pages behind them are the standard to compare against. My own SEO portfolio is public for exactly that reason.

“What Do You Need From Me?”

Underrated question, and the answer tells you whether they have done this before. Real campaigns need things from the client. Access to the site, approval on content, occasional subject knowledge that only the business has, sometimes a decision about which services to prioritize. A provider who says they need nothing from you is planning to work entirely from a template.

“How Do You Build Links?”

Listen for the word “network”. Private blog networks, link packages, and anything described as a monthly quota of links are the tactics that produce cleanup bills two years later. Acceptable answers involve content someone would actually cite, digital PR, industry directories that predate SEO, partnerships, and guest contributions to real publications. Slower, and it does not come back to bite you. Ask directly whether they use PBNs. The reaction to the question is informative regardless of the answer.

“What Happens If I Leave?”

Ask early. The answer lands much harder once you are committed. Who owns the content written for you. Who owns the Search Console and Analytics properties. Who owns the Google Business Profile. Whether the pages stay on your site if the relationship ends. Owners have lost their entire content library and their own Business Profile this way. Get the ownership terms written into the agreement. A provider who resists that is telling you something.

“What Are You Going to Report, and How Often?”

Monthly is standard. What matters is what the report contains. Rankings alone are a vanity metric, particularly if the provider picks which keywords to show. A useful report ties positions to impressions, traffic, and enquiries, and it states plainly what was done that month and what comes next. Ask to see a sample report from a live account with the client details removed. Providers who do good reporting are usually pleased to show it.

“What Would Make You Turn Down This Job?”

The most revealing question on the list, and almost nobody asks it. A specialist who has been doing this a while has turned down work. Sites where the business model does not suit search, markets where nobody is searching, budgets too small for the competition involved, owners wanting guarantees nobody can give. An answer of “nothing, we can help anyone” means you are talking to sales.

Two Answers That Should End the Meeting

Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Google’s results. Guaranteeing position one means picking a phrase nobody searches for. That is generally what the guarantee turns out to mean. Refusal to explain the method. “Proprietary process” is not a method. You are entitled to know what will be done to your own website, and vagueness at the sales stage does not improve after the contract.

Start Smaller Than the Retainer

The cheapest way to evaluate any provider is to buy a single piece of work first. An SEO audit gives you a documented list of what is wrong, some sense of the effort involved, and a direct read on whether this person knows their trade. Generic findings that could apply to any site tell you as much as good ones do. Then decide on the retainer with actual evidence instead of an impression from a meeting. SEO Company To-The-TOP! has worked this way since 2007, owner to specialist with no handoff in between, and the questions above are ones I would want asked of me.

Frequently Asked Questions

What questions should I ask an SEO agency before hiring?

Ask what happens in the first ninety days. Who does the daily work. How they build links. What lands in the report. What becomes of your content and accounts if you leave. Then ask what would make them turn a job down. That question sorts specialists from salespeople faster than the rest of the list combined.

How do I know if an SEO company is legitimate?

Plain-language explanations of method. Specific client outcomes instead of a logo wall. Refusal to guarantee positions. A willingness to say SEO suits your business poorly. Evasiveness on link building or reporting is the warning sign worth acting on.

Should I sign a long SEO contract?

Six months is reasonable, since the work genuinely takes that long to show anything. Twelve months with no exit clause deserves scrutiny. Whatever the term, get content and account ownership written down before signing, because that clause causes more trouble at the end than the length ever does.

Is a cheap SEO service worth trying first?

Usually not. Under $500 a month buys too few hours for real work, so the output tends to be automated links and thin pages. Cleaning that up later costs more than starting properly. A one-off audit is the better low-risk way to test a provider.

SEO Company To-The-TOP! Contact Information

Address

1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

Phone

(403) 308-5949

Hours of Operation

Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Map

Get Directions